Annuities

Annuities that turn savings into income you cannot outlive.

An annuity is a contract with an insurance carrier: you place money with them, and they guarantee something in return, growth, income for life, or both. We are independent, represent over 40 carriers, and will walk you through the three main types side by side so you can see exactly how they differ.

How an annuity can help you

Most retirement worry comes down to two questions: will I lose what I saved, and will it last as long as I do? Annuities are built to answer both. They are the only financial product that can pay you a guaranteed income for the rest of your life, no matter how long you live or what the market does.

  • Lifetime income guaranteed by the issuing carrier that you cannot outlive
  • Principal protection on fixed and fixed indexed contracts
  • Tax-deferred growth, you pay no tax on gains until you withdraw
  • Typically avoids probate by paying your named beneficiary directly
  • Rates are often higher than bank CDs on comparable terms, though annuities are not FDIC insured and are not bank deposits
  • Optional riders for income growth, long-term care, or a death benefit

1. Fixed annuities

The simplest type. The carrier credits a set interest rate for a set number of years, much like a bank CD but usually at a higher rate and with tax deferral. A multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) locks the rate for the full term, so you know the exact value on day one and at maturity. Best for savers who want certainty above all else and do not need market upside.

  • Rate and principal are guaranteed by the issuing carrier, subject to its claims-paying ability
  • No market risk and no annual fees in most contracts
  • Terms commonly run 2 to 10 years
  • Predictable, easy to compare, easy to understand

2. Fixed indexed annuities

Your principal is still guaranteed by the issuing carrier, but instead of a flat rate your interest is linked to a market index such as the S&P 500. You are not investing in the index or in the stock market. In a good year you share in the gains up to a cap or participation rate. In a bad year your credited interest is 0%, you do not lose money to the market. This is the safe-money middle ground: more upside than a fixed annuity, none of the downside of being invested directly.

  • Principal protected with a 0% floor, your worst year is a flat year
  • Market-linked growth subject to caps, spreads, or participation rates
  • No advisory or management fees on most contracts we place; optional riders carry a charge
  • Optional income riders that grow your future paycheck the longer you wait

3. Variable annuities

A variable annuity invests your money in subaccounts that work like mutual funds. Your account value rises and falls with those investments, so there is more growth potential and real risk of loss. Variable annuities also carry ongoing fees: mortality and expense charges, subaccount fees, and rider charges. They are securities products and require a securities license. We do not place variable annuities, and we will tell you honestly when your existing one is already doing its job.

  • Growth tied to market subaccounts, with the risk of loss
  • Ongoing fees that fixed and fixed indexed contracts usually do not have
  • Sold only by securities-licensed representatives through a prospectus
  • We will review one you already own and explain what it costs you

How the three types compare

Fixed gives you a known rate with no risk. Fixed indexed gives you market-linked upside with no market loss. Variable gives you the most upside and the most risk, plus fees. Choosing well is less about which product is best in general and more about which risk you are unwilling to take with this particular money.

  • Want certainty and a set rate: fixed annuity
  • Want growth potential without losing principal: fixed indexed annuity
  • Want full market participation and accept loss and fees: variable annuity
  • Want a paycheck for life: any of the three can add lifetime income, the guarantees differ

Immediate vs deferred

An immediate annuity starts paying you within about a year, useful if you need income now. A deferred annuity grows first and pays later, useful if you are still a few years out from retirement. Both fixed and fixed indexed contracts come in either form.

Funding an annuity

You can fund an annuity with after-tax savings or move qualified money over with a direct rollover from a 401(k), 403(b), TSP, or traditional IRA. Done as a direct transfer, there are no taxes and no penalties. We handle the paperwork with your current custodian so nothing touches your hands and nothing becomes taxable by mistake.

  • 401(k), 403(b), and TSP rollovers
  • Traditional and Roth IRA transfers
  • 1035 exchanges from an existing annuity or life policy
  • After-tax, non-qualified funds

Annuity rates in Michigan right now

Annuity rates move week to week and they are not the same at every carrier. A five-year multi-year guaranteed annuity at one company can pay noticeably more than the same term at another, and the bank down the street rarely wins that comparison. Because we are independent and contracted with more than 40 carriers, we shop the whole list for you instead of selling one company's product. Ask for the current rate sheet and you will see the top guaranteed rates by term on one page.

  • Current MYGA and fixed annuity rates by 2, 3, 5, 7, and 10 year terms, subject to change
  • Fixed indexed annuity caps, participation rates, and bonus offers
  • Carrier financial strength ratings shown next to each rate
  • Updated as carriers change rates, usually every few weeks

Annuity vs CD vs bond vs money market

People comparing safe places for retirement money usually look at all four. A CD is FDIC insured and taxed every year even if you do not touch the interest. A bond can lose value if you sell before maturity. A money market rate can drop the month after you open it. A fixed annuity locks your rate for the full term, grows tax deferred, and can be turned into lifetime income later. The right choice depends on when you need the money and whether taxes now or taxes later hurts you more.

  • CD: FDIC insured, taxed annually, often a lower guaranteed rate; an annuity is not FDIC insured
  • Bond: market value can fall before maturity
  • Money market: rate can change at any time
  • Fixed annuity: rate locked for the term, tax deferred, income options

Who an annuity is right for, and who it is not

We will tell you when an annuity is not the answer. If you may need all of this money within the next couple of years, or it is your only emergency fund, a surrender period works against you. Annuities fit best when you are protecting money you intend to keep for the long term or turn into income.

  • Good fit: you are 55 to 80 and want income or principal protection
  • Good fit: you are rolling over a 401(k) and want to stop losing sleep over market swings
  • Poor fit: this is your emergency cash or you need it all within two years
  • Poor fit: you want full market participation and accept the losses that come with it

Where we help

Certified Benefit Advisors is located at 475 East Columbia Avenue, Suite 8 in Battle Creek, Michigan. We serve all of Michigan, including Kalamazoo, Jackson, Grand Rapids, Lansing, Coldwater, Marshall, Albion, Hastings, and the surrounding counties, and are licensed in about ten other states. We meet in our office or in your home, and there is never a fee for our time.

Annuity resources at no cost and with no obligation

Pick whichever one is useful to you. A licensed agent from our Battle Creek office prepares it and sends it the way you ask. There is never a charge and never any pressure to buy.

Rate sheet at no cost

This week's top Michigan annuity rates

A current, one-page comparison of multi-year guaranteed (MYGA) and fixed indexed annuity rates available to Michigan residents from the carriers we represent, with rates subject to change and carrier availability, with terms, minimums, and any surrender details in plain language.

  • Current guaranteed rates by term: 2, 3, 5, 7, and 10 years, subject to change
  • Which carriers are paying the most right now, and their ratings
  • Penalty-free withdrawal amounts and surrender schedules side by side

No cost and no obligation. We never sell your information. By submitting, you agree we may contact you about the request.

Buyer's guide at no cost

The plain-English Annuity Buyer's Guide

A short guide written for people who are tired of jargon. It explains fixed, fixed indexed, and variable annuities side by side, what caps and participation rates really mean, how income riders work, and the questions to ask before you sign anything.

  • A one-page comparison chart of the three annuity types
  • The 10 questions to ask any annuity agent before you buy
  • The most common mistakes we see people make with retirement money

No cost and no obligation. We never sell your information. By submitting, you agree we may contact you about the request.

Second opinion at no cost

Second opinion on the annuity you already own

Already have an annuity and not sure it is doing what you were told it would do? Send it over. We will read the contract, tell you what it actually costs you each year, what it currently guarantees, and whether it is worth keeping. Sometimes the answer is yes, and we will say so.

  • What your contract really pays, in writing, not in sales language
  • Fees, caps, riders, and where you are in the surrender period
  • Whether a 1035 exchange would help you or just restart the clock

No cost and no obligation. We never sell your information. By submitting, you agree we may contact you about the request.

Frequently asked questions

What are the three main types of annuities?

Fixed, fixed indexed, and variable. A fixed annuity credits a set interest rate. A fixed indexed annuity credits interest linked to a market index with a 0% floor so you cannot lose principal to the market. A variable annuity invests in market subaccounts, with both higher growth potential and real risk of loss plus ongoing fees.

Can I lose money in an annuity?

In a fixed or fixed indexed annuity your principal is guaranteed by the issuing carrier, subject to its claims-paying ability, so market losses do not reduce it. You can still lose value by withdrawing more than the contract allows during the surrender period, which triggers a surrender charge. A variable annuity can lose value outright because it is invested in the market.

How is an annuity different from a CD?

Both can guarantee a rate for a term. An annuity is backed by the issuing insurance carrier rather than FDIC insurance and may pay a higher guaranteed rate, grows tax deferred until you withdraw, can pay income for life, and passes directly to your named beneficiary without probate.

What fees do annuities charge?

Most fixed and fixed indexed annuities we place have no annual fee. If you add an optional rider, such as a guaranteed income or enhanced death benefit rider, that rider carries a stated annual charge. Variable annuities typically charge mortality and expense fees plus subaccount fees every year.

What is a surrender period?

It is the number of years you agree to leave the money in the contract, often 5 to 10 years. Most contracts let you take out about 10% per year penalty free. Withdraw more than that before the period ends and the carrier applies a surrender charge that declines each year.

How are annuities taxed?

This is general information and not tax advice; please confirm with your tax advisor. Growth is tax deferred. With after-tax money, only the gain is taxable when withdrawn. With rollover money from a 401(k) or traditional IRA, withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income just as they would have been in the original account. Withdrawals before age 59 1/2 may also carry a 10% IRS penalty. We are not tax advisors, so confirm your situation with your CPA.

Am I too old, or too young, to buy an annuity?

Issue ages vary by carrier and product, commonly from about 18 up to age 85 or 90. Most of our annuity clients are between 55 and 80 and are protecting money they will need for income in the next few years.

How much does it cost to talk to you about an annuity?

Nothing. We are paid by the carrier when you choose a contract, so there is no advisory fee and no charge for a review, a comparison, or a second opinion on something you already own.

Can I move my 401(k) or IRA into an annuity?

Yes, through a direct rollover or transfer. Handled that way it is not a taxable event and there are no penalties. We coordinate the paperwork with your current custodian.

What happens to my annuity when I die?

The remaining value goes to the beneficiary you name on the contract, generally without going through probate. Some contracts include an enhanced death benefit. Beneficiaries can usually choose a lump sum or a series of payments.

Get a plain-English annuity comparison, no cost, no pressure.

Independent. Local to Battle Creek. Serving all of Michigan and 10+ states.